The student voice of American River College since 1955

The American River Current

The student voice of American River College since 1955

The American River Current

The student voice of American River College since 1955

The American River Current

Lil Wayne’s album stuns, Logic’s flops

Photo courtesy of Young Money Records

Sept. 28 was an exciting day for Hip Hop fans, as two of the genre’s biggest names dropped albums on the same day: Lil Wayne’s “Tha Carter V” and Logic’s “Young Sinatra IV.”

Wayne’s “Tha Carter V” is a stunning album and can be considered one Wayne’s best projects to date. Logic’s album: “Young Sinatra IV” is just another album, because there is nothing too exciting about it. Both albums had plenty of anticipation and hype, but Wayne’s “Tha Carter V” drew in more focus because he hadn’t released an album since 2011. Fans of Wayne won’t be disappointed as the rapper hasn’t lost a step in his five year silence, delivering one of his best projects to date. Logic, on the other hand failed to impress, falling flatter than fans expected him to.

Originally planned for released in 2014, “Tha Carter V” was held back by Birdman, co-owner of Cash Money Records, as Wayne wanted to be released from the music label after Birdman violated the contract’s terms and agreements.

This is Wayne’s first album to be released under a label other than Cash Money Records, which he signed with in 1995.

The album features plenty of well-known artists including Kendrick Lamar, Travis Scott, label mate Nicki Minaj, and Wayne’s daughter, 19 year-old Reginae Carter.

The first song, “Don’t Cry,” which features the late rapper XXXTentacion, starts with vocals that are similar to one’s in the song “Jocelyn Flores,” as Wayne raps about his emotions, hard situations throughout his life and his morality.

The track ends with Wayne rapping: “triple extension on my afterlife, rest in paradise,” paying homage to his collaborator, X, who was shot in South Florida earlier this year.

The fifth track of the album: “Let it Fly” features Houston rapper Travis Scott. Scott ranted in a series of Tweets in 2014 about the song he had recorded with Wayne and how he wants his album to be “free.”

On the track, Wayne demonstrates his skill with wordplay by using a rhyming scheme through a story that shows his skills.

“Mona Lisa,” featuring Kendrick Lamar, was one of the most anticipated tracks on the record. Featuring Kendrick and his distinct voices, the track sounds like it was recorded either before or after the recording of Lamar’s third album: “To Pimp a Butterfly.”

Wayne had an extra five or six years to work on this album and perfect it in the way he wanted to while he was dealing with his lawsuit with Birdman which was settled for $51 million in June.

This is a damn-near perfect album by Wayne. One that will be remembered for ages and could possibly be Wayne’s best album to date.

Photo courtesy of Def Jam Records

“Young Sinatra IV,” (stylized as “YSIV”) is the final installment to Logic’s Young Sinatra series.

“YSIV” is Logic’s fourth studio album and makes 2018 the tenth straight year that he has released a project.

The first song of the album is Logic thanking his fans. Logic actually put his phone number on Twitter to tell fans to leave a voicemail and he will incorporate them in to his album.

“YSIV” has plenty of features, including Jaden Smith, Hailee Steinfeld, Wale, and the entire Wu-Tang Clan. Logic was able to get the entire Wu-Tang Clan, under one song called “Wu-Tang Forever.”

It is a very old-school 1990s, New York style track that doesn’t necessarily fit with the album but feels like more of a brag from Logic that he was able to score the Wu-Tang Clan for this album.

The ninth track on the album, the title track “YSIV,” is more of a freestyle that Logic had already used to announce the album in a video on Youtube, but just a few things were tweaked in the album version and the freestyle was used as the second verse.

Logic uses the song to remember the passing of the Pittsburgh rapper, Mac Miller, who overdosed in early September. Logic says Miller is a big reason why he wanted to rap full-time and to start his Young Sinatra series.

“YSIV” is a fun album, but it’s an album just to put on if you want to have music in the background. Logic has been putting out the same projects for the past three or four years now. “YSIV” could be the worst release of the rapper’s career.

A new release every year from Logic isn’t fascinating, nor is it something to gear up for a ton of excitement. The rapper is writing himself into a corner in order to meet the yearly release schedule.

Sure this album has great boom-bap kicks to it, and plenty of trap sounds throughout, Logic calls it “the best album he has ever made,” but it’s not; it’s just another Logic album.

One thing that differentiates Wayne’s “Tha Carter V” from Logic’s “YSIV” is the effort that is put into the album. Wayne might have had an extra five or six years to put into the album because of the lawsuit, but the added time helped turn it into one of his best records to date.

Logic’s album, on the other hand, sounded like there wasn’t enough time or effort put into it. Logic just wanted to meet his yearly album quota. He made another album because he wants to make money or appease his fans, but whichever reason it is, it wasn’t the best decision.

View Comments (5)
More to Discover

Comments (5)

All The American River Current Picks Reader Picks Sort: Newest

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

  • M

    Mychael JonesOct 15, 2018 at 6:27 pm

    I will agree with Gabe. I just listened to the YSIV album and it has a nice sound but it sounds more like a love letter to hip hop than a groundbreaking album. Whereas Wayne deals with his personal issues Logic talks about them in passing without giving too much depth. It’s a fine album but nothing to be applauded for.

  • F

    ForumOct 15, 2018 at 1:12 pm

    I can actually smell the bias against Logic coming from this article. It’s funny too considering his album came 2nd after Lil Wayne’s; clearly a ‘flop’. This isn’t me just saying your a hater but obviously you don’t like Logic lol

    • G

      Gabe CarlosOct 15, 2018 at 2:48 pm

      As a fan of Logic, I was honestly disappointed in the effort he put into this album. I’ve been listening to Logic since 2012 and this is the only album of his that just didn’t do it for me — it fell short of my expectations.

      His first album, “Under Pressure,” has been his best album so far. I also really like “The Incredible True Story” and how it is a concept album, but “Under Pressure” related to me most on a personal level. I’ve seen Logic twice and would definitely see him again. His “Bobby Tarantino” mixtapes are amazing too.

      I’ve listened to “YSIV” multiple times and it has disappointed me as a Logic fan and a rap fan.

  • P

    PrajwalOct 14, 2018 at 10:11 pm

    Bro logic didn’t say it’s his best album made .his fans said that ,get your facts right

    • G

      Gabe CarlosOct 15, 2018 at 12:35 pm


      Logic put out a tweet where he flew his fans from across the country to listen to “YSIV.” In that tweet, Logic said “The best album I’ve ever made? The fans seem to think so.” Logic heavily implied that he thinks it is the best album he has ever made. Logic also personally flew these people out to listen to it, so they were in no place to disagree in saying that the album was not good.