Student Senate votes not to recall embattled Trustee who questioned Holocaust

Los Rios Student Trustee Cameron Weaver, left, and Clubs and Events Board Vice President Mary Stedman listen while the Student Senate discusses efforts to recall Weaver at its meeting Thursday. The Senate decided not to recall Weaver, in spite of his comments casting doubt on whether the Holocaust actually happened. (Photo by Jordan Schauberger)

The Associated Student Body Student Senate voted seven to two against a proposed recall effort of Los Rios Student Trustee Cameron Weaver, who came under fire for casting doubt on whether the Holocaust actually took place in a 55-minute interview with the Current on Sept. 16.

Following the vote, Sen. Tamara Dunning, one of the two board members who voted to recall Weaver, said that the board members voted from the wrong perspective.

“I think they (the board members who voted against recalling Weaver) voted from friendship,” said Dunning. “They didn’t vote from an ‘elected official’ mindset.”

During public comment, Weaver said that he has been “misrepresented” by all of the media coverage of his comments.

“Despite the fact that I’ve been completely misrepresented in ARC Current’s initial coverage as well as all the subsequent local news coverage, I recognize that this entire event has cast the district in a negative light,” said Weaver. “From the very bottom of my heart, I am truly sorry that I am the epicenter of this.

“The misrepresentation that I willingly, without thinking – I guess you could say, set myself up for –  has caused a really tragic trainwreck of a situation to transpire.”

Clubs and Events Board Vice President Mary Stedman, speaking in the meeting as a student, said that she does not support the recall of Weaver.

“For those who think that this is anti-Semitic, I would have to formally and kindly disagree,” said Stedman. “This is being skeptical on a piece of history, something that we should not be taking so emotionally. … If we’re going to punish one person’s opinion, what’s to say we shouldn’t punish everyone for their opinion.”

Bruce Pomer of the Jewish Community Relations Council, a former member of the Los Rios Board of Trustees, said those comments were “incredible” and “completely miss the point.”

“We can repeat it a million times – facts are facts. When you deny something documented on film, by the observations of millions of people, that’s very difficult especially for an educational institution,” said Pomer. “The reason you have to bring this up is to make sure it doesn’t happen again … Are we going to deny what happened to African-Americans for the first two hundred years of this country’s history? It’s the same.”

Pomer, who has been in talks with the district regarding Weaver, said that he thinks the district needs to provide an event for genocide awareness.

“When you get this kind of reaction, why do we even have a school?” said Pomer.

CAEB President Justin Nicholson said during the meeting that without any action on his opinion, Weaver’s comments don’t matter.

“I’ve learned to accept everyone’s opinions for whatever they are because an opinion is just that, an opinion,” said Nicholson. “Until someone acts on that opinion, it is nothing.”

Three of the four Los Rios Associated Student Body student governments would have to agree for a recall to go to the voters.

Jorge Riley, who served as acting ASB Student Senate President in 2013, gathered 200 of students who wanted Weaver recalled. Riley said that the Center for Leadership and Development told him that he hadn’t gathered enough.

Riley feels the students voices aren’t being heard.

“He got off here because of the buddy system,” said Riley. “But just because he has friends at this school doesn’t mean he has friends at the other schools.”

Acting Student Senate President David Hylton said that he found it suspicious the Current has refused to provide the board with a copy of the audio regarding where Weaver originally made the comments that are under scrutiny.

“What is the adequate justification to keep 70 percent of a recording secret?” asked Hylton.

The Current has released the sections of the 55-minute interview pertaining to the Holocaust.

During the discussion about the vote to recall Weaver, Director of Legislative Affairs Laurie Jones said the she would vote against.

Dunning said that a vote cannot be announced during the discussion and that it might influence the board. She called for the vote to be suspended so that Jones’s statement can be investigated.

The board voted to not suspend the vote and to not investigate Jones’s statement.

After the vote, Hylton said that the discussion of recalling Weaver will be struck from all future meetings.

Additional reporting by John Ferrannini

Print Friendly, PDF & Email

About the Author

Jordan Schauberger
Jordan is a third-semester student on the Current, where he serves as design editor. He is double majoring in journalism and art new media and plans to transfer after graduation.

2 Comments on "Student Senate votes not to recall embattled Trustee who questioned Holocaust"

  1. Whether or not one finds Weaver’s comments personally insulting, one must ask how an individual lacking basic critical thinking skills managed to find his way onto our Student Senate. Ditto for Hylton and his fellow senate cohorts.

    The failure of our Student Senate to recall Weaver merely reinforces my long-term negative opinion of our senate.

  2. What unacceptable and reductionist comments these people employ to mitigate criticism and their refusal to acknowledge fault. Stedman’s comments are especially pernicious given that she conflates questioning present history, and discredit it by saying we cannot authentically corroborate the events ourselves.

    There is certainly an approach to being questioning and critical of historical events – but to outright deny their existence or it ever happening is no such an adequate mode of doing so. It is apparent that the easiest of the choices presented to the board were to vote to move on with their lives and dedicate themselves to “real issues.” How truly fitting of a board who has nothing but their best interests and future aspirations of politics in mind above all other concerns.

Leave a Reply to JM Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published.


*